"We need to have open borders so people can do the work Americans are unwilling to do."
"Everyone's family immigrated here some time."
"It's a human rights issue, man."
Those are just a few of the primary arguments you hear from the pro-illegal immigration crowd, a crowd composed almost (but not entirely) of liberals. What I think the right does a poor job of is explaining how the policies of the left, while superficially beneficial to illegal immigrants, and cloaked in humanitarian concern, are really resulting in an extension of the poverty and suffering these people were trying to escape.
Here in NYC, Mayor Bloomberg had an idea - send them all to Detroit. Only a liberal could come up with an idea like that and not be tarred and feathered. Even though he won't use the un-PC term "illegal," Mayor Bloomberg is right to be concerned about the plight of illegal aliens and their impact on our communities and culture. My ideas aren't as fancy as Mayor Bloomberg's suggested implementation of an American Lebensraum policy, but I think they'd be just as effective.
I think pretty much everyone agrees that immigration is, in and of itself, a good thing for American society. It's one of the reasons America's always been at the cutting edge, as families, histories, and cultures melt into the semi-homogeneous societal soup we like to call America. The problem is when people from other cultures come over here, insulate themselves in their own hyphenated communities, and, rather than experience and become part of America, exist in a little outpost of their native country, superimposed on ours.
Illegal aliens in a lot of neighborhoods in NYC don't have much of a chance to even pursue the American dream. Often they're exploited and overworked and underpaid, their bitterness and anger fueling divisive politics and redistributionist nonsense. Of course, the flip side of this is that the companies who exploit and use illegal alien labor are oftentimes taking business and jobs away from taxpaying legal American workers.
It's a double whammy, and the real losers are you and me, as we see liberal immigration policies fill our communities with illegal aliens who live a life in the margins of society, surrounded by their own ethnic group in inner-city ghettos that extend like third-world beacheads into our communities, school districts, and neighborhoods.
The answer is simple - we need to document all incoming immigrants, and offer entry based on the needs of our economy, and the skills these people offer. I can only speak for myself, but, frankly, New York City doesn't need any more taxi drivers. Mayor Bloomberg's right on that.
If America's going to continue to be the melting pot we like to think of ourselves as, we need to make sure that we don't oversaturate ourselves. There are areas on Northern Boulevard in Queens where I can't even tell what the stores sell, because all the signs are in Chinese, or Korean, or some such. We need to make sure that the immigrants we allow in have skills that allow them to succeed in America, and experience the American dream. That's the kind of immigration reform we need.
--
Posted By Tax Nomo to
RightWire at 5/03/2011 04:24:00 PM